Premises, Premises
A Peer-Enforced Marketplace for New Ideas
Not logged in     

Archive
December 2004 update: The archiving system described below has been partly obsoleted by a wonderful decision written in October by Magistrate Judge Arlander Keys, for the U.S. District Court in the Northern District of Illinois. Keys's decision establishes that webpage snapshots from the Internet Archive (aka the "Wayback Machine") are legally admissible as evidence of what existed online in the past. Hey-- that's easy! You can read a report on the decision from Stanford Law School's Center for Internet and Society here.

You can see the Internet Archive's records of Premises, Premises here.

Note that as of this writing, there's a six-month delay between the time that the Internet Archive spiders a site and when the corresponding snapshot becomes searchable online-- so the preceding link won't lead to any Premises, Premises ideas that have been posted recently.

The Telewizja Polska USA, Inc. vs. Echostar Satellite Corporation decision is great, but Internet Archive crawls are relatively infrequent. For a finer-grained trail of what-appeared-when on this site, accurate down to the day, Premises, Premises ideas are still timestamped, archived, and notarized in accordance with the method described below.

-=-=-=-=-=-=-

Here's how Premises, Premises provides foolproof evidence that its ideas were posted on the dates indicated. This procedure protects the ideas' owners by proving that they thought of them first (if, in fact, they did).

Procedure
The entire contents of the Premises, Premises database are periodically written out to an archive file which is then compressed with gzip, a standard Unix utility, and hashed to an unique key code, a "fingerprint," using the standard MD5 algorithm. The integrity of the archive is guaranteed because if the file is altered in any way, it will not produce the same key. The archive files and their MD5 keys are both stored on the site's server, as listed below. Printouts of the archive filenames and corresponding keys are then logged by a notary public in the real world, thereby proving the existence of the database in its archived state before the time that its code was notarized.

The archive files are not downloadable by the public, but if a dispute arises over an idea posted here, this site's administrator will be more than happy to provide these files as evidence to any investigator. Contact Paul, pspinrad at premisespremises dot com.

About MD5
The MD5 algorithm generates "fingerprints" of input files that are 128 bits long. In RFC 1321, the algorithm's inventor, Ronald Rivest, explains:

It is conjectured that it is computationally infeasible to produce two messages having the same message digest, or to produce any message having a given prespecified target message digest.
For details, see RFC 1321


Archive Date MD5 Key Comment
152334_05112005_Premise_archived.sql.gz 2005-05-11 2c3905268afd80ca732af279828e0e86 Notarized 11 May 2005 by Monica Diaz, Notary Public, Commission #1533442, San Francisco County, CA
123249_06162003_Premise_archived.sql.gz 2003-06-16 910d22a2f5477a2bed4d3c83e0a61447 Notarized 16 June 2003 by Paul C. Moffett, Notary Public, Commission #1413308, San Francisco County, CA
121521_06162003_Premise_archived.sql.gz 2003-06-16 1ebbc9cfa2a6169be9e65cedbeaf39af Notarized 16 June 2003 by Paul C. Moffett, Notary Public, Commission #1413308, San Francisco County, CA
142918_05212003_Premise_archived.sql.gz 2003-05-21 e7c44acb032b8a1d465b1f368c5d37a6 Notarized 22 May 2003 by Paul C. Moffett, Notary Public, Commission #1413308, San Francisco County, CA
142609_05212003_Premise_archived.sql.gz 2003-05-21 08b6aa1e28cc1707d4dbfde2636a0deb Notarized 22 May 2003 by Paul C. Moffett, Notary Public, Commission #1413308, San Francisco County, CA
111955_03252003_Premise_archived.sql.gz 2003-03-25 5701b19b2628cb7ff0b692d37fd18acd Notarized 22 May 2003 by Paul C. Moffett, Notary Public, Commission #1413308, San Francisco County, CA